The Social Credit proposals explained in 10 lessons - Lesson 8
In the previous issue of "Michael" we published Lesson 6 on the compensated discount, and Lesson 7 on the history of the banking control in the United States, which showed, among other things, that even if you have honest politicians in office, they won't be able to change the financial system unless they have the support of the population, which has to be educated on the subject.
In this issue, we publish Lesson 8, which explains that there is no need to create a new political party to have the Social Credit principles applied into the laws of our countries, but simply to educate the people on the money issue.This is followed by the first pages of Louis Even's booklet, A Sound and Effective Financial System, which is a recapitulation of what we have learned so far. We have printed a 100-page booklet that contains the 10 lessons that you can order from our office at $8 each (postage included) if you live in Canada; $11 for the U.S.A., and $13 for overseas. Good reading!
Alain Pilote
To rely on a party is a delusion
(The following text is taken from Louis Even » brochure "What Do We Mean By Real Social Credit? — Above political parties)
The implementation of Social Credit would institute true democracy: economic democracy by making each consumer capable of obtaining the basic necessities of life from the country's production; political democracy insofar as the people can make known to their elected representatives and to their governments what they expect of them and to demand results. (Demos, people; kratein, to reign. — Democracy: the people's sovereignty.)
Any Social Crediter who is even slightly informed knows very well that today supreme power is not exercised by the people or their governments, but by a financial clique. Statesmen like Gladstone, Wilson, and others said this explicitly. Mackenzie King said in 1935 that the greatest battle of all times was "between the financial powers and the people." A battle in which he did not engage, no doubt because he considered the financial powers too strong and the people too weak.
The people are weak indeed; and it is understandable that they are weak when first, they know nothing about public matters and what goes on behind the scenes; and second, when instead of teaching them about these things those who are ruling the country divide them into political factions that are fighting against each other. It is not more factions that will create unity, they will instead create division. It is division and many factions that serve merely to increase weakness in the country.
It is a man of genius named C. H. Douglas who discovered the great truth of Social Credit; it is he who founded the Social Credit school. He most certainly knew better what Social Credit meant as far as democracy is concerned than those little fellows of our homeland who would like to make Social Credit into the instrument of their race to power, or at least a platform for their ambitions in search for a seat in Parliament.
Douglas said in a lecture given in Newcastle-upon-Tyne on March 19, 1937, that there are in England two major obstacles to true democracy and the first of these obstacles is the system of parties.
The same goes for Canada and the solution to the problem does not consist in feeding the system of parties, but in weakening it. That is to say to neutralize or disband the parties in existence and not creating another division within the people, but by uniting the citizens, all the citizens of the country, without party distinctions to allow them express their common will to their Members of Parliament, whoever these Members of Parliament are, and whatever their political colours. To put the focus on what happens between elections, when the fate of the citizens is at stake, more than during elections when it is the politicians who are battling each other.
We need to unite the citizens. And we can begin by making them understand that they all want the same fundamental things, then we can convince them that by thus putting pressure together to get what they all want, they would inevitably obtain their goal.
It is Major Douglas who on another occasion in Liverpool, October 30, 1936, said,
"The people's sovereignty, i.e., their effective ability to give orders, would increase with their unanimity, and if people all wanted a uniform result there could be no possibility of parties, and there could be no resistance to their demand."
That is a very good line of conduct, perfectly in keeping with common sense.
You will never be able to get everybody in agreement around a ballot box. But you could very well get them in agreement on the results to be demanded from politics, if you make it a point to set these results in the order of their universality and urgency: economic security, a sufficient amount of goods today and guaranteed for tomorrow, the freedom for each one to choose his occupation and lifestyle. Everybody wants these things; and, as Douglas points out, even those who do not want them for others, would want them for themselves.
Why then bring attention towards the ballot box, towards the thing that divides instead of applying oneself to effectively uniting all people around the issues over which everybody can be in agreement?
Never was an important reform obtained by the formation of a new political party. Most of the time if a party is established with the goal of major reform, it dies because of electoral failure; and if by chance it comes to power, it comes up against so many obstacles that it becomes paralyzed and has no further objective than to stay in power without doing any more than the traditional parties. To overcome obstacles, it lacked strength: which is that of a people sufficiently informed in the political field.
Besides, a reform cannot come out of an election. A reform results from a natural and democratic process, from the maturation of a well-cultivated idea; it results from its acceptance and demand by a sufficient number of people to create a general will which can be expressed without falling victim to the hazards of electoral results.
Social Credit will enter into the country's legislation when it will have become the object of a general will or demand, which will encourage all political parties to welcome it into their programs. To confine it into a political party is to link its fate to the same electoral fate of that party. And it can mean moving backward instead of forward.
A new idea is spread through propaganda and it takes roots through study. The newer the idea and the greater its repercussions, the more its propagation and implantation call for effort, time, and perseverance. The cause that propagates this idea has much more need of apostles than members of parliament.
The instigators of new parties no doubt consider that the people's political education would take too much time, if they ever even thought about it. A quick vote seems to be a more usual method and a faster one to them. The result of this is tombstones, which are not even visited by those who supported these defunct parties. A fair number of these gentlemen have since contentedly settled down under the wings of traditional parties that they had previously eloquently denounced.
The people's strength must be built up so that their pressure on governments exceeds the strength of the financial powers. It is not in a parliament that people can build up their strength. It is where the people are — which is outside of parliaments. And that is the place of a true Social Credit Movement.
Douglas and electioneering
The Social Credit Secretariat, an organization founded by Major Douglas himself has republished an address given by the founder of Social Credit on March 7, 1936. That day, Douglas was not speaking to the general public, but to Social Crediters.
In that address, Douglas recommends a policy of pressure and strongly condemns the formation of political parties, especially that of a "Social Credit" party. He condemns this kind of effort, not only because it is doomed to failure before it starts, but also because it imprisons and obscures the beautiful philosophy that Social Credit is, in putting it into politics and the ballot box. Douglas goes so far as to say:
"If you elect a Social Credit party, supposing you could, I may say that I regard the election of a Social Credit party in this country as one of the greatest catastrophes that could happen."
The proper function of a Member of Parliament, explained Douglas, is to receive and pass on to the government the expression of the legitimate will of its constituents. The proper function of a government is to receive this demand and order the experts to follow it up (the experts meaning the financiers for financial matters, etc). One must not tell these experts how to go about it, but point out the result to be achieved and demand this result.
And the role of the people is to become aware of objectives that they commonly want and to express this will to their representatives. It is where it must begin, from where it must be launched, with the voters. Therefore, instead of giving the importance to the elected representative, we must give it to the voters.
In Douglas's words: "If you agree that the object of sending a set of men to Parliament is to get what you want, then why elect a special set of men, or a special party at all? The men who are there should get you what you want — that is their business. It is not their business to say how the goal is to be reached. How things are done is the responsibility of the expert."
The experts must be told what the citizens want and this demand must come from the citizens themselves.
Electioneering has perverted democracy. The only thing political parties can achieve is to divide people, weaken their strength and lead them to disappointments, so to add a new party can only add another disappointment under another name. A disappointment all the more disastrous if the adventure drags with it the name of an excellent cause like that of Social Credit.
Louis Even
(Note: The following text is the introduction to Louis Even's book In this Age of Plenty.)
For those who are completely new to the Social Credit philosophy, two points must immediately be clarified: 1. Social Credit is by no mans a form of Socialism; 2. Social Credit is not a political party.
Not Socialism
Because of the word social in the term "Social Credit", some people erroneously assume it to be a form of Socialism, and automatically reject it. On the contrary, Social Credit is the best way to fight Socialism and Communism, and to protect private property and individual freedom. A Dominican Father, who had studied the Social Credit proposals, even wrote: "And if you want neither Socialism nor Communism, bring Social Credit in array against them. It will be in your hands a powerful weapon with which to fight these enemies."
And in 1939, a Commission of nine theologians appointed by the Bishops of Quebec found that Social Credit was not tainted with Socialism nor Communism, and was worthy of close attention. In fact, Social Credit wants to make every member of society a real capitalist, a shareholder in the wealth of the country. If the expression "social" credit scares some people, Douglas's financial proposals can also be referred to under other names: public credit, economic democracy, or New Economics.
Not a political party
Concerning the issue of political parties, it is true that parties called "Social Credit" existed in the past, and that is why some people may be confused: a "Social Credit" party existed on the federal scene in Canada for a while, and was even in power in the Province of Alberta, Canada, from 1935 to 1971, and in the Province of British Columbia, from 1952 to 1991 (except for three years, from 1972 to 1975). None of these provincial parties applied Social Credit. (The very day he took office as premier in 1952, Bennett, B.C. "Social Credit" leader, even said that his party would do absolutely nothing to apply Social Credit principles. Actually, there was nothing even closely related to real Social Credit in this party or its platform; it should have been more accurately called "conservative".)
The fact is that there is no need for a so-called "Social Credit" party to have C. H. Douglas's Social Credit principles implemented. These principles can be applied by any political party presently in office, whatever its name — Liberal, Conservative, etc. Some people may have thought that promoting "Social Credit" parties was the better way to promote Social Credit, but C. H. Douglas and Louis Even thought exactly the opposite.
As Douglas and Louis Even pointed out, the creation of "Social Credit" parties was even a nuisance, and did nothing but to prevent the implementation of real Social Credit. For example, as soon as you use the words "Social Credit" to name a political party, you just close the minds of people of other parties to even study Social Credit, since they will consider it only as another party to be fought.
Real democracy means that elected representatives are sent to Parliament precisely to represent their constituents, and to express the will of their constituents. So the point is not to create new parties, and divide the people even more, but to unite the people around common objectives, and then to put pressure on the Government to implement these objectives. This method of pressure politics is the one advocated by the Michael Journal.
In a speech given to Social Crediters on March 7, 1936, Douglas said that the idea that a Social Credit party should exist (in any country) was a "profound misconception". He even added: "If you elect a Social Credit party... it would be to elect a set of amateurs to direct a set of very competent professionals. The professionals, I may tell you, would see that the amateurs got the blame for everything that was done."
This is precisely what happened in Alberta in the 1930s. (Douglas wrote a very interesting book on that subject, entitled "The Alberta Experiment", from which the following information is taken.)
The Alberta experiment
William Aberhart was a principal of Calgary High School, who commanded a province-wide audience every Sunday with his religious broadcasts. He came across a book on Social Credit and, being so carried away by this new light, he began to use his radio program to preach the "gospel" of Social Credit, and to mobilize support for it. Hundreds of study groups soon appeared across the province, and a majority of Albertans became in favour of Social Credit. The ruling party in Alberta at the time, the United Farmers, was also open to Social Credit, but said that it could only be applied nation-wide, and not provincially. Aberhart disagreed, and decided to present Social Credit candidates in the 1935 provincial election, and he captured 56 of the 63 seats in the provincial legislature. They were all new to politics, being a "set of amateurs", and were no match for the Financiers.
For example, when Aberhart took office, instead of listening to Douglas's advice, he went to Ottawa to seek financial assistance, and an economic adviser, Mr. Robert Magor, was given to him. This Mr. Magor had obviously only one objective in mind: to discredit Social Credit. Measures were adopted that were just the opposite of Social Credit, and that is what Douglas called "a policy of capitulation to orthodox finance... Almost every mistake of strategy which could be made in Alberta had been made."
It must also be mentioned that Aberhart, although sincere enough, had also little knowledge of Social Credit, and did not understand its technical basis, which led him, in an effort to simplify Douglas's ideas, to often distort them. In the following years, fifteen Social Credit bills were voted on by the Alberta Government, but vetoed by higher authorities (either disallowed by the Federal Government, or ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court).
One point of contention was obviously that money and banking was under federal jurisdiction, according to the Canadian Constitution. Douglas explained to Aberhart that Alberta could bypass this difficulty by making use of its own credit by establishing a provincial credit system, since the Constitution grants to the provinces the right to "raise loans upon the sole credit of the Province." As Douglas wrote in The Social Crediter of September 11, 1948: "When Mr. Aberhart won his first electoral victory (in 1935), all he did was to recruit an army for a war (against the monopoly of credit). That war has never been fought."
Aberhart had learned from his mistakes during his first years in office, and was ready, after World War II, to take up the fight again, but he unfortunately died in May, 1943. His successor, Ernest Manning, soon made it clear that he was not prepared to take up that fight again, and finally declared, in 1947, that his government would no longer do anything to implement Social Credit in Alberta. (Incidentally, after retiring from politics, Ernest Manning became a director of a bank.)
So those who say that "Social Credit is that funny money scheme tried in Alberta, where it failed", are dead wrong. Social Credit did not fail in Alberta, for the simple reason that it was never tried: all the attempts to implement Social Credit policies were opposed and defeated by a centralized power. As Douglas said, if Social Credit was absurd and worthless as an effective answer to the Great Depression of the period, the best way to have this demonstrated would have been to permit the Government of Alberta to go ahead with a Social Credit policy. The credit monopolists feared that even a partial application of Social Credit would prove so successful that every effort had to be made to prevent this from taking place.
* * *
The only effective way to have the Social Credit proposals implemented by governments is therefore not to promote so-called "social credit" parties, but to make Social Credit principles known to the population — by distributing our Michael leaflets, and, above all, to solicit subscriptions to our Michael Journal — in order to create a public pressure that will be strong enough to get the government — of any party — of our country to issue its own money, debt free, and to implement Douglas's Social Credit principles.
We firmly believe that the Social Credit principles, once implemented, would be a very efficacious way to eliminate poverty (in the countries in which they are implemented). For the first time in history, absolute economic security, without restrictive conditions, would be guaranteed to each and every individual. So, dear reader, go ahead and study the following pages. You will find them most enlightening. Our hope is that this study will get you to take action to make this Social Credit solution known to your fellow countrymen, in order to create a public pressure that will be strong enough to get the government of your country to issue its own money, debt free, and to implement Douglas's Social Credit principles.
Alain Pilote



