With the recent developments in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the fact that robots are capable of performing most human tasks, a major upheaval is about to take place in the labour market. Millions of workers will be replaced by robots that neither sleep nor eat, can work around the clock, and perform these tasks much faster than human beings ever could.
This raises a fundamental question. If all these unemployed workers, displaced by AI, will no longer receive wages, what will be their source of income?
Several leaders in the business world have addressed this issue. At the Aspen Ideas Festival, held on June 27, 2025, Ford Motor President Jim Farley stated that AI "will literally replace half of all white-collar workers in the United States." Likewise, Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia—the company best known for manufacturing the advanced micro chips that power the world's most sophisticated AI models—declared at the Milken Institute Global Conference on May 6, 2025: "Every job will be affected [by AI], and immediately. It is unquestionable."
As a result, a growing number of business leaders and politicians have suggested that the time has come to introduce some form of basic income or guaranteed annual income.
More recently, Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla, the company that manufactures the Optimus humanoid robots, stated that society will eventually have no choice but to adopt a high universal basic income—not merely enough to survive—distributed in the form of cheques issued by the federal government.
The idea of providing every citizen with a guaranteed income is steadily gaining support under various names—universal basic income, citizens'income, guaranteed income, universal allowance, basic income, and others. One reason is the growing recognition that today's social programs are inadequate. Another is that technological progress will continue to eliminate the need for human labour in more and more sectors, thus depriving many people of their employment income.
As early as 1930, economist John Maynard Keynes wrote in Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren:
"We are being afflicted with a new disease of which some readers may not yet have heard the name, but which they will be hearing a great deal about in the years to come – namely, technological unemployment. This refers to unemployment caused by the fact that we are discovering ways to reduce the need for labour at a faster rate than we are able to find new opportunities for that labour."
During the forced shutdown of nearly all workplaces during the COVID-19 lockdowns that began in 2020, many governments introduced emergency funding to assist those who had lost their wages, as well as businesses facing bankruptcy. Naturally, these measures cost billions of dollars and caused public debts to rise to unprecedented levels.
Everyone agreed that, despite this massive increase in debt, governments had no alternative, since people could not simply be left to starve. Yet, all the programs were subject to various eligibility rules, with the result that many people fell through the cracks and received little or no assistance, or had to wait several weeks before receiving any help. Moreover, these programs were cumbersome to administer, requiring extensive investigations and a large bureaucracy.
In Canada, many public figures—including journalists and politicians—suggested that the federal government should adopt some form of basic income or guaranteed annual income. For example, on April 21, 2020, fifty senators—nearly half the members of the Canadian Senate—sent a letter to then Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, urging him to introduce a basic income program to prevent more Canadians from "falling through the cracks" and to create "a positive legacy for all Canadians." According to the Basic Income Canada Network, every adult in Canada should receive $22,000 per year.
In April 2020, in a letter concerning the pandemic, the Catholic bishops of Quebec proposed "the permanent establishment of a guaranteed minimum income for all citizens." Support for the idea also came from the highest level of the Church. In a letter addressed to popular movements on Easter Sunday, April 12, 2020, Pope Francis wrote:
"This may be the time to consider a universal basic wage that would acknowledge and honour the noble and essential tasks you carry out." (The letter was written in Spanish, and the Pope used the expression salario universal, which corresponds to the English expression basic income.)
The most recent and concrete development on this issue in Canada was the introduction in the Senate, on May 28, 2025, of Bill S-206 by independent Senator Kim Pate. The bill "requires the Minister of Finance to develop a national framework to ensure that every person over the age of 17 in Canada has access to an adequate basic income," and specifies that "participation in the labour market or in a training program would not be a condition of eligibility." However, since being referred to committee on November 6, 2025, the bill has not been debated further in the Senate. It therefore remains legally alive but dormant in committee, with no significant activity. (The governing Liberal Party has not made it a priority, while the Progressive Conservative party has opposed it.)
As we can see, the idea is being discussed, but one fundamental question remains: How should this basic income be financed? Will the country have to incur even more debt? Another concern is that such an income could eventually be paid in the form of a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC), subject to numerous conditions governing how the money may be spent, thereby increasing government control over the population.
The solution: the Social Dividend
As we have seen, no real solution is proposed to finance a basic income scheme other than increasing public debt or taxing the wealthy. Regular readers of the Michael Journal know that Clifford Hugh Douglas and Louis Even proposed a far more effective solution: the Social Dividend, which would require neither higher taxes nor additional public debt.
A Dividend is a sum of money paid every month to every citizen, without conditions, regardless of income or employment status. It recognizes every citizen as a co-heir to the country's natural resources and to the accumulated benefits of progress—that is, all the inventions developed over the centuries—which Douglas called the cultural heritage. This Dividend would be financed by newly created, interest-free money issued through a National Credit Office, or the nation's central bank.
However, the dividend makes sense only when implemented together with the two other principles of Economic Democracy:
1. New money belongs to society, not to private corporations (commercial banks), and should be issued by a public institution established by the State—a National Credit Office. In reality, money derives its value from the country's productive capacity, that is, from its natural resources and from workers willing and able to develop those resources.
2. The second principle of Economic Democracy is the Compensated Discount—a discount applied to retail prices and reimbursed to the retailer—to prevent price increases and therefore eliminate inflation.
Why give everyone an income, and why call it a Dividend?
When we speak of someone receiving dividends, we usually think of a shareholder receiving a share of a company's profits. Yet it is equally true that every citizen, every member of society, is a co-owner of a vast and highly productive real capital.
It has already been established that money, or financial credit, belongs to society as a whole at the moment it is created. It belongs to society because it is based on real credit—the productive capacity of the nation. That productive capacity certainly depends in part on the labour and skills of those who participate directly in production. But to an even greater extent, and increasingly so, it is based on other factors that belong to everyone.
First, there are natural resources, which are not the product of any human being. They are a gift from God, freely given for the benefit of all. Then there are all the inventions that have been made, improved, and handed down from one generation to another. Today, this accumulated knowledge constitutes the greatest factor of production. No individual can claim greater ownership than anyone else over this progress, since it is the fruit of countless generations.
Of course, people today are needed to put this inheritance to use, and they deserve to be rewarded for doing so. They receive that reward in the form of wages, salaries, and other forms of remuneration. Likewise, an investor who does not personally work in the company in which he has invested still has the right to receive a share of the profits because of his invested capital.
As it is, the greatest real capital in modern production is the immense accumulation of discoveries and inventions that enables us to produce more goods with less human labour than ever before. Since every living person is an equal co-heir to this ever-growing capital, everyone is entitled to share in the fruits of production.
The employed person will be entitled to both his wages and the Dividend. The unemployed person will have no wages, but will still be entitled to the Dividend. We call it a Social Dividend because it is the income derived from social capital.
Karl Marx claimed that labour (the proletariat) created all wealth. Adam Smith argued that the capitalist (the person who invests money in a business) also deserves a share. Yet both overlooked what Douglas called the cultural heritage—the immense inheritance of natural resources and accumulated inventions—which today accounts for more than 90 percent of a nation's productive capacity.
Indeed, when speaking of the poor, it is entirely appropriate to describe them as the disinherited, for they are the ones deprived of an inheritance that rightfully belongs to them.
The Social Credit Dividend is therefore based on two realities: our inheritance of natural resources and our inheritance of the inventions created by previous generations.This is what Pope John Paul II wrote in his 1981 encyclical Laborem Exercens (On Human Work, no. 13):
"Through his work man enters into two inheritances: the inheritance of what is given to the whole of humanity in the resources of nature, and the inheritance of what others have already developed on the basis of those resources, primarily by developing technology, that is to say, by producing a whole collection of increasingly perfect instruments for work. In working, man also "enters into the labour of others."
Filling the gap in purchasing power
Another reason for issuing a Dividend to every citizen is mathematical: the present financial system creates a chronic shortage of purchasing power.
Whenever production is financed, production follows. And when production occurs, it distributes the money used to finance it. This money—paid out in wages, profits, and industrial dividends—becomes purchasing power for those who receive it. However, two facts must be recognized:
First, industry never distributes purchasing power at the same rate that it builds prices.
Second, production does not distribute purchasing power to everyone. It distributes income only to those whom it employs.
Even if banks charged no interest whatsoever on the money they lend, there would still be a shortage of purchasing power, because the wages distributed can never buy the entire production, whose prices include many other costs besides wages.
Some economists claim that production automatically creates sufficient purchasing power to purchase everything produced (Say's Law). Yet the facts prove otherwise.
The Scottish engineer Clifford Hugh Douglas was the first to demonstrate scientifically this chronic shortage of purchasing power and to propose a practical solution known as Economic Democracy or Social Credit. Douglas explained this shortage through what he called the A + B Theorem.
'A' cannot buy 'A + B'
A producer must include all production costs in the selling price of his products if he wishes to remain in business. The wages paid to employees—which Douglas called "A payments"—represent only one part of the total cost of production.
The producer must also include many other costs that are not distributed as wages, such as payments for raw materials, taxes, banking charges, maintenance, replacement of machinery, etc. Douglas called these costs "B payments."
The selling price of a product must therefore include both wages (A) and all additional costs (B). The selling price is therefore A + B. It is obvious, then, that A cannot buy A + B. The wages distributed (A) can never purchase the total value of production (A + B). Consequently, there is a chronic shortage of purchasing power built into our current financial system.
When the finished product is offered for sale, it has an affixed price. But part of the money included in that price may have been distributed six months, a year, or even several years earlier. Another portion will not be distributed until after the product has been sold and the merchant has spent his profit. Still another portion may not be distributed for ten years, when machinery whose depreciation has been included in today's prices is finally replaced with new equipment.
Then there are people who receive money but save it rather than spend it. That money is reflected in prices, but it is no longer available as purchasing power for those who need to buy the goods. The repayment of bank loans and the present tax system further widens the gap between prices and purchasing power.
Some may object that the businesses receiving the "B payments"—those supplying raw materials, machinery, and other inputs—also pay wages to their own employees, so that part of the B payments eventually becomes A payments.
This does not invalidate what has just been explained. Those wages are simply paid at another stage of the production process, and they, too, become part of the price of another product, whose selling price will again be A + B. The gap therefore continues to exist.
Even if wages are increased in an attempt to catch up with prices, those higher wages automatically become part of production costs and are therefore reflected in higher prices. Nothing is solved.
If consumers are to be able to purchase the entire production of the country, they must receive additional income beyond wages, at least equal to B. That is precisely the role of the Social Credit Dividend, paid every month to every citizen of the country.
Let us emphasize once again that this Dividend would be financed through new money created by the nation itself, not through taxpayers'money, since taxes merely redistribute income that already originates from wages.
Technological progress replaces the need for human labour
Another major flaw in the present financial system is that production distributes purchasing power only to those whom it employs. Yet the greater the role played by machines, the smaller the role played by human labour. Production continues to increase while the amount of labour required steadily decreases.
A conflict therefore arises between technological progress, which reduces the need for human labour, and a financial system that distributes purchasing power only through paid employment.
Yet everyone has the right to live. Everyone has the right to the necessities of life. The goods of the earth were created for all people, not only for those who happen to have paid employment.
That is why Economic Democracy would accomplish what the present system fails to do. Without eliminating the reward for work, it would provide every citizen with a regular income called the Social Dividend—an income attached to the person, not to employment.
Today, the problem is not a shortage of production. The problem is a failure of distribution. What is therefore needed is distributive justice, achieved through the distribution of a Dividend. Pope Benedict XVI wrote in his encyclical Caritas in Veritate:
"The social doctrine of the Church has unceasingly highlighted the importance of distributive justice and social justice for the market economy" (no. 35)... Economic life undoubtedly requires contracts, in order to regulate relations of exchange between goods of equivalent value. But it also needs just laws and forms of redistribution governed by politics, and what is more, it needs works redolent of the spirit of gift" (no. 37).
In Caritas in Veritate, Benedict XVI places great emphasis on the economy of gift, on gratuitousness in both personal relationships and institutions. Not everything can be measured in terms of wages. Much good is accomplished through volunteer work, for example.
Under a Social Credit system, where every citizen enjoys economic security through the Social Dividend, mutual assistance and volunteer service would naturally flourish.
God Himself continually showers humanity with gifts through the abundance of natural resources and the food He provides. The Social Dividend would simply reflect this divine generosity and these freely given gifts of God. To the extent that production can dispense with human labour, the purchasing power represented by money must reach consumers through a channel other than wages.
The replacement of human labour by machines in production should be a blessing. It should free people from purely material concerns and allow them to devote themselves to other human activities beyond merely earning a living. If, instead, automation becomes a source of anxiety and deprivation, it is simply because we refuse to adapt the financial system to technological progress. We insist on restricting income to paid employment alone.
Is technology an evil therefore? Should we rebel and destroy every machine because it takes away our jobs? Certainly not. If a machine can perform a task, so much the better. It enables people to devote their free time to other pursuits—activities they freely choose and truly enjoy.
But this is possible only if they receive an income to replace the wages lost when machines and robotics take over their work. Otherwise, the machine, which ought to be humanity's ally, becomes its enemy by depriving people of income and making it impossible for them to live.
But if a person is no longer employed in paid work, what will he do with his free time? He will devote it to freely chosen activities. It is during our free time that we can truly develop our personality and cultivate the talents God has given us, putting them to good use.
Moreover, it is during their free time that men and women can fulfill their family, religious, and social responsibilities: raising their children, practising their faith (to know, love, and serve God), and helping their neighbours. Raising children is the most important work in the world. Yet because a mother who remains at home to care for her children does not receive a salary, society often considers that she is doing nothing—that she is not working!
Being freed from the necessity of working merely to produce the necessities of life does not mean becoming lazy. It simply means that individuals will be finally free to choose the activities that truly interest them. Under a Social Credit system, there would be a flourishing of creative activity. Many of humanity's greatest inventions and masterpieces of art were produced during periods of free time.
As C. H. Douglas wrote: "Most people prefer to be employed, but on things they like rather than on the things they don't like to be employed upon. The proposals of Social Credit are in no sense intended to produce a nation of idlers... Social Credit would allow people to allocate themselves to those jobs to which they are suited. A job you do well is a job you like, and a job you like is a job you do well."
Let us continue educating the public in support of a basic income financed without taxation through our nation's central bank.



